The Concrete and the Memory Inside Benjamin Netanyahu’s Heartland

The Concrete and the Memory Inside Benjamin Netanyahu’s Heartland

Seven in the morning in Beersheba smells like diesel exhaust, damp limestone, and cardamom boiling over a low flame.

At the edge of the Negev desert, before the heat turns the asphalt soft, the men at the open-air market are already arguing. Not shouting. Arguing with the practiced, rhythmic cadence of people who have debated the exact same borderlines, tax brackets, and security cabinets for forty years. To an outsider watching from a glass-walled newsroom in Tel Aviv or Washington, these voters are often flattened into a single, predictable demographic block. They are called "the base." They are treated like a monolith carved out of desert stone.

That caricature misses the entire point.

If you want to understand why Benjamin Netanyahu has remained the gravitational center of Israeli politics for nearly three decades—surviving indictments, splintered coalitions, mass street protests, and the unprecedented shock of October 7—you cannot look at parliament floor speeches. You have to sit on a plastic chair next to a retired mechanic in a southern development town while he explains why he still trusts a man his own children despise.

Listen closely.

The Architecture of a Grievance

To understand the loyalty inside Likud’s traditional strongholds—places like Beersheba, Ashdod, Netivot, and the working-class neighborhoods of Jerusalem—you have to rewind the tape seventy years.

Imagine a hypothetical family arriving at the port of Haifa in 1954. Let us call them the Mizrahis, though their real names were Ben-Ami, Peretz, and Ohana. They came from Morocco, Iraq, Yemen, and Tunisia, often leaving behind established businesses and centuries-old communities. Upon arrival, the fledgling state’s Labor Zionist establishment—predominantly European, secular, and socialist—directed them away from the coastal centers of power. They were sent to ma'abarot, transit camps of tin shacks and canvas tents pitched in the periphery, meant to populate the borders and build the agricultural infrastructure of a country fighting for survival.

For decades, those transit camps hardened into concrete "development towns." The factories were local, the schools were underfunded, and the cultural message from the elites in Tel Aviv was unmistakable: assimilate into our European vision of modernity, or remain on the margins.

Then came 1977.

When Menachem Begin, the fiery leader of the right-wing Likud party, swept into power, he did not just win an election. He handed a microphone to millions of Mizrahi Israelis who felt like second-class citizens in their own homeland. Begin spoke their language of traditionalism, pride, and unapologetic nationalism. He told them they were not peripheral. He told them they were the core.

Benjamin Netanyahu, despite his secular upbringing in Jerusalem and his elite education in Philadelphia and at MIT, inherited that political covenant. Over decades, he mastered the art of standing at a podium in Ashkelon or Dimona and reminding the crowd that the judicial establishment, the media, and the opposition in Tel Aviv still looked down on them. Whenever critics attacked Netanyahu, his supporters in the heartland did not just hear an attack on a politician. They heard an echo of 1954.

A Walk Down Rager Boulevard

Walk down Rager Boulevard in Beersheba on a Tuesday afternoon and you will see the modern reality of that history. It is a city of wide avenues, gleaming cyber-security office parks, and, just two blocks away, aging concrete apartment blocks where laundry hangs from rusted balconies.

Here, politics is not an abstract debate over constitutional theory. It is visceral.

Consider a composite portrait drawn from dozens of conversations across southern Israel: a fifty-eight-year-old woman we will call Miriam, who runs a small bakery near the old central bus station. Miriam wakes up at four every morning. She watches the news on Channel 14, the right-leaning network that serves as the ideological hearth for Netanyahu’s supporters. When you ask her about the judicial overhaul that tore the country apart throughout 2023, she does not cite legal scholars. She talks about her nephew, who served in an elite combat unit, and her frustration that unelected judges in Jerusalem seemed to hold more power over border policy than the politicians she voted for.

"They think we don't understand democracy," she says, wiping flour from her forearms. "We understand it fine. We vote, we win, and then the courts tell us our vote doesn't count."

Her perspective is sharp, coherent, and deeply felt. Yet walk ten minutes north toward Ben-Gurion University, and the air changes completely.

In the cafés frequented by students, doctors, and tech engineers, the exact same city produces a mirror-image diagnosis. Here, people talk about October 7 not as a collective tragedy that demands unity behind a seasoned leader, but as an unforgivable breach of the basic contract between a state and its citizens. For them, Netanyahu’s long-standing strategy of managing the conflict rather than resolving it collapsed in a single morning. They point to the years of Qatari cash allowed into Gaza, the distraction of the judicial crisis, and the refusal to take personal responsibility for the intelligence and military failures under his watch.

Two neighborhoods. One city. Two entirely incompatible realities.

The Invisible Stakes of the Heartland

What makes this divide so volatile is that both sides believe they are fighting for survival.

In Western commentary, Netanyahu’s durability is frequently reduced to pure cynicism—a master manipulator clinging to office to outrun his corruption trials. While critics and opposition leaders argue that his legal battles heavily dictate his political calculus, reducing his support to mere gullibility ignores the structural forces keeping him afloat.

Think of Israeli politics not as a conventional left-right spectrum, but as a tectonic fault line between two competing visions of what the state should be.

On one side sits what sociologists call the "First Israel"—largely secular, globally connected, economically concentrated along the Tel Aviv tech corridor, and fiercely protective of liberal democratic institutions and an independent Supreme Court. On the other side stands the "Second Israel"—more traditional, religious, geographically peripheral, and convinced that strong, centralized executive power and uncompromising military deterrence are the only things standing between them and annihilation in a hostile neighborhood.

Netanyahu did not invent this fault line. He simply built his fortress directly on top of it.

I remember standing in a square in Netivot during an election cycle a few years ago, watching the crowd wait for him to arrive. The heat was suffocating. The campaign music was deafening. When his armored convoy finally pulled up and he stepped onto the stage, the reaction wasn't just partisan enthusiasm. It was relief. People reached out their phones as if trying to capture proof that the prime minister had actually come to their dusty corner of the map, that he knew their names, that he saw them.

It is easy to mock that from afar. It is much harder to offer an alternative that carries the same emotional weight.

The Cracks in the Concrete

Yet even in the deepest strongholds of the heartland, the foundation is no longer untouched.

The war that began in October 2023 altered the physics of Israeli life. In towns like Sderot and Ofakim—communities that voted overwhelmingly for Likud for decades—the grief is not theoretical. Every street has a memorial poster. Every family knows someone who was killed, kidnapped, or deployed for months on end in Gaza and along the northern border with Lebanon.

In these towns, loyalty is now colliding with raw, unfiltered anger.

Look at what happens in the living rooms of religious-Zionist and traditional families across the south and the West Bank settlements. For years, Netanyahu sold himself as "Mr. Security"—the indispensable statesman who could speak fluent, authoritative English on American television while keeping Israel safe from regional wars. That brand took a devastating blow when Hamas breached the border fence and held towns inside Israel for hours.

Some lifelong voters have quietly peeled away, unable to reconcile the image of the master strategist with the reality of the worst security failure in the nation's history. Others, however, have doubled down. In times of existential terror, human psychology rarely favors radical experimentation. When rockets are flying and regional powers are threatening escalation, many voters look at the opposition—a fragmented collection of former generals and centrist politicians—and decide that the devil they know is safer than an untested alternative.

This is the paradox that baffles outside observers. The very crisis that critics believed would end Netanyahu’s career overnight simultaneously activated the deep survival instincts that keep his coalition intact.

The Weight of the Next Generation

To see where this story goes next, stop listening to the politicians and watch the twenty-two-year-olds coming home from reserve duty.

Sit at a falafel stand in Ashdod on a Thursday night when soldiers in dusty olive uniforms drop their heavy gear onto the pavement and order food. Many of them grew up in Likud households. Their parents framed photos of Menachem Begin on the wall and voted for Netanyahu in every election since 1996.

Ask these young soldiers what they think, and you rarely get a neat partisan slogan. You get exhaustion. You get a generation that has spent its early twenties fighting in tunnels and patrolling northern ridges while watching politicians in Jerusalem bicker over ultra-Orthodox military exemptions and coalition budgets.

One young reservist, speaking quietly while waiting for his order, put it plainly: he didn't care about the grievances of 1954, and he didn't care about the editorial pages in Tel Aviv. He cared about whether the state would still be functional enough for him to build a business, buy an apartment, and raise kids without wondering if the next siren would go off at six in the morning.

That pragmatism is the quietest, most dangerous threat to the old political order.

Netanyahu’s political genius has always relied on keeping the old battles alive—us against them, the periphery against the elites, the pragmatist against a naive world. It is a powerful, intoxicating narrative that has carried him through seven terms and made him the longest-serving prime minister in Israel’s history.

But narratives require belief to survive.

As dusk settles over Beersheba, the heat finally breaks. The market stalls are hosed down, washing away the day's bruised fruit and cardboard boxes. The old men pack up their backgammon boards and walk slowly back toward the concrete apartment blocks, past the glittering tech towers rising along the highway. The city looks quiet from a distance, solid and unmoving against the desert sky—until you stand close enough to see the hairline fractures running straight through the stone.

IZ

Isaiah Zhang

A trusted voice in digital journalism, Isaiah Zhang blends analytical rigor with an engaging narrative style to bring important stories to life.