The Paper Slip That Shakes a Nation (And How Israel Really Votes)

The Paper Slip That Shakes a Nation (And How Israel Really Votes)

The booth is a flimsy thing. Blue plastic panels, barely wider than a cafe table, set up inside a sunlit elementary school classroom in Tel Aviv or a community center in Haifa.

You step behind the curtain. Nobody is watching. In front of you sits a divided plastic tray overflowing with small white paper slips, each roughly the size of a playing card. Every slip carries one, two, or three bold Hebrew letters—and sometimes Arabic letters beneath them—representing a political party. You pick one slip. You fold it into a tiny blue envelope. You walk out, drop that envelope into a slotted metal box, and walk into the Mediterranean glare.

That’s it. No touchscreens. No pens. No ranking candidates from one to five. Just a slip of paper the size of a coaster.

Yet that single piece of paper sets off a chain reaction so volatile, so intricate, and so deeply personal that it can topple a government before the ink on the coalition agreements has even dried. Between April 2019 and November 2022, Israelis stepped behind that blue curtain five times in less than four years. Five national elections. Five days off work—because Election Day in Israel is a paid national holiday, designed specifically so every citizen can make it to the ballot box, even if many spend the afternoon at the beach after voting.

To an outsider, Israeli politics looks like an exhausting, endless soap opera. To understand why, you have to stop looking at it through the lens of American or British elections and step inside the room where the deals are actually cut.

The Arithmetic of Survival

Let’s introduce a hypothetical voter to make the math real. Call her Maya. She is a thirty-four-year-old software engineer living in Ramat Gan. On Election Day, Maya walks into her local school, steps behind the curtain, and chooses a party list.

Notice the word: list.

When Maya votes, she does not vote for a prime minister. She does not even vote for a local representative from her neighborhood. Unlike the United States, where districts carve up the map, or the United Kingdom, where constituencies send individual members to Parliament, the entire State of Israel functions as one single electoral district. Every vote from the snowy slopes of Mount Hermon in the north to the desert port of Eilat in the south goes into the exact same national pot.

Israel uses a system of pure proportional representation. There are 120 seats in the Knesset, Israel’s parliament, a number rooted in ancient history—the Knesset HaGedolah, or Great Assembly, convened in Jerusalem by Ezra and Nehemiah in the fifth century BCE.

Here is how the math works, according to the rules set out by Israel’s Central Elections Committee and the Basic Law: The Knesset. To get a single seat in those 120 chairs, a party doesn't need to win a geographic district. It simply needs to cross the electoral threshold—currently set at 3.25 percent of all valid votes cast nationwide.

Think about what 3.25 percent means. If roughly four and a half million Israelis vote, a party needs around 145,000 to 150,000 votes to enter parliament. Cross that line, and the party immediately gets four seats. Fall short by even a few hundred votes—as the New Right party famously did in April 2019, missing the threshold by roughly 1,400 ballots—and every single one of those votes vanishes into thin air.

Because the bar is relatively low, no single party has ever won an outright majority of 61 seats in the entire history of the modern state, which was founded in 1948. Not David Ben-Gurion’s Mapai in the early decades. Not Menachem Begin’s Likud in 1977. Not Benjamin Netanyahu at the height of his dominance.

Never.

The Night the Real Election Begins

Election night in Israel has a specific sound. At 10:00 PM sharp, the polling stations close, and the three major television networks simultaneously broadcast their exit polls. Instantly, the living rooms of Jerusalem, Beer Sheva, and Nazareth erupt. Pundits shout over bar charts. Party headquarters either pop champagne or go dead silent.

Yet anyone who has lived through an Israeli election cycle knows a secret: the exit polls are only the opening act. The real election starts after the votes are counted.

Consider what happens next.

Because no party reaches 61 seats alone, the entire system runs on coalitions. Imagine you are trying to build a dinner table with 120 chairs, and you need at least 61 people to agree on what to eat, who pays the bill, and who sits at the head of the table—except half the guests refuse to sit next to each other, and a small group of four guests threatens to flip the table over if they don't get their favorite dessert.

That is coalition building in the Knesset.

Once the Central Elections Committee certifies the official results—a process that takes up to eight days, including the counting of "double envelopes" cast by soldiers on military bases, diplomats abroad, hospital patients, and prisoners—the spotlight shifts to a quiet stone residence in Jerusalem.

The President of Israel, a largely ceremonial head of state, invites representatives from every party that crossed the 3.25 percent threshold for televised consultations. One by one, party leaders sit on plush armchairs across from the President and recommend which Knesset member should get the first crack at forming a government.

According to Israel's Basic Law: The Government, the President hands that mandate to the candidate with the best realistic chance of assembling a 61-seat majority—usually, though not always, the leader of the largest party. That candidate gets 28 days to put the puzzle together, with the option of a 14-day extension if the President agrees.

Why Tiny Parties Hold Giant Megaphones

This is the part that baffles observers abroad, and frankly, infuriates plenty of Israelis at home. Why do small parties—factions holding just six, eight, or ten seats—wield enough power to dictate national policy, control massive ministries, or bring down a prime minister?

Let’s go back to our hypothetical voter, Maya, and add another character. Call him David, a seminary student in Bnei Brak, and Leila, a pharmacist in Haifa. Each votes for a distinct party reflecting their community’s deepest anxieties and priorities.

In a majoritarian system like America’s, Maya, David, and Leila would be forced into two giant umbrellas—big-tent parties where internal compromises happen behind closed doors before Election Day. In Israel, those compromises happen in broad daylight after Election Day.

Suppose the largest party wins 32 seats. To reach 61, its leader needs 29 more. They turn to three smaller parties holding 11, 10, and 8 seats. Add them up: 32 plus 11 plus 10 plus 8 equals 61.

Suddenly, the leader of that 8-seat party holds a trump card. If they walk away, the math collapses to 53, and the government falls. Every small partner in a razor-thin coalition knows they are the load-bearing wall. They use that leverage to demand key cabinet posts—Finance, Defense, Interior, Education—along with specific clauses written into binding coalition agreements.

Political scientists and historians, including analysts at the Israel Democracy Institute, have long pointed out this structural tension. On one hand, proportional representation gives virtually every slice of Israeli society a voice in parliament—secular liberals, ultra-Orthodox Jews, religious nationalists, Russian-speaking immigrants, and Arab citizens. Nobody is locked out of the conversation just because they live in the wrong zip code.

On the other hand, representation without stability exacts a heavy price.

The Invisible Stakes Behind the Curtain

If you want to feel why people care so fiercely about these elections, look beyond the parliamentary math to what sits on the table.

Israel does not have a single, entrenched written constitution. Instead, it is governed by a series of Basic Laws passed by the Knesset over the decades, alongside rulings from the Supreme Court. Because a simple majority of 61 lawmakers can pass or amend legislation—and in many cases alter the balance of power between the courts, the military, and the cabinet—an election isn't merely a change in tax rates or healthcare spending.

It is an argument over the identity of the country itself.

Think about the questions every Israeli government has to confront:

  • Security and borders: How to manage existential threats from militant groups like Hamas and Hezbollah, navigate relations with Iran, and decide the future of the West Bank and Gaza.
  • Religion and state: Who controls marriage and divorce (which in Israel fall under religious courts rather than civil ones), whether public transit runs on Shabbat, and whether ultra-Orthodox men are drafted into mandatory military service alongside their secular peers.
  • The courts and democracy: How much authority the Supreme Court should have to strike down laws passed by the Knesset, and how judges themselves are appointed.

When Maya steps behind that blue plastic curtain, she isn't just picking a manager for the economy. She is casting a vote on whether her younger brother serves three years in the army while another community receives exemptions. She is voting on whether her neighborhood grocery store stays open on Saturday morning. She is voting on the very rules of the democratic referee.

How the Votes Actually Turn Into Seats

The math behind seat allocation has its own quirks—specifically, a mathematical formula known as the Bader-Ofer method, adopted in 1973 and named after the two Knesset members who proposed it, Yohanan Bader and Avraham Ofer.

Here is an intuitive way to picture it. Imagine the 120 seats are slices of a giant cake, and only parties that cleared the 3.25 percent doorway get to sit at the table. First, the total valid votes of all qualifying parties are divided by 120 to determine the "index"—the exact price of a single seat. Each party gets as many seats as its vote total can buy outright.

Inevitably, there are leftover votes and a handful of unassigned seats—usually five to eight slices of cake still sitting on the platter.

Instead of giving those leftovers to whichever party simply has the highest remaining number of raw votes, the Bader-Ofer formula favors larger parties and allows two parties to sign a surplus-vote agreement before the election. By pooling their leftover votes together, two ideologically aligned parties—say, two right-wing factions or two center-left lists—can snag an extra seat between them that neither could have won alone.

It is a game of inches played out in spreadsheets at 3:00 AM while the rest of the country sleeps.

The Five-Election Fever Dream

Between 2019 and 2022, that spreadsheet broke down entirely.

The crisis wasn't born from a sudden collapse in voter turnout; Israelis continued showing up at the polls at rates that would make American election officials weep with envy—hovering between 67 percent and over 71 percent. Rather, the deadlock stemmed from a deep polarization around a single question: whether Benjamin Netanyahu, Israel's longest-serving prime minister, should remain in office while standing trial on corruption charges (charges he has consistently denied).

The electorate split down the middle into two rival camps—not strictly left versus right, since many of Netanyahu's fiercest critics were staunchly right-wing politicians themselves, but pro-Netanyahu and anti-Netanyahu blocs.

Election after election ended in a stalemate:

  • April 2019: Netanyahu’s bloc reached 60 seats—one agonizing seat short of 61—when former Defense Minister Avigdor Lieberman refused to join over a dispute regarding ultra-Orthodox military conscription. Rather than let the President give another candidate a chance, the Knesset voted to dissolve itself.
  • September 2019: Another stalemate. Neither bloc could assemble 61 seats.
  • March 2020: As the COVID-19 pandemic struck, Netanyahu and his chief rival, former military chief Benny Gantz, finally forged an uneasy "unity" government. It collapsed within months over a failure to pass a national budget—one of the few automatic triggers under Israeli law that forces immediate new elections.
  • March 2021: An extraordinary, improbable coalition emerged. Eight wildly different parties—spanning right-wing nationalists, centrists, left-wing social democrats, and, for the first time in Israel’s history, an independent Arab party, Ra’am—joined forces to form a 61-seat government led first by Naftali Bennett and later by Yair Lapid. That fragile bridge lasted just over a year before defections stripped away its majority.
  • November 2022: Voters returned to the booths a fifth time, delivering a decisive 64-seat majority to Netanyahu and his right-wing and religious allies.

Even after that result, the tectonic plates kept grinding. Within months, the new government’s push to overhaul the judiciary triggered the largest street protests in Israeli history, bringing hundreds of thousands of citizens into the streets week after week—until October 7, 2023, when Hamas launched its devastating attack on southern Israel, plunging the country into war and reshaping every political calculation overnight.

Why Voters Keep Showing Up

You might think five elections in four years, followed by constitutional upheaval and war, would make Israelis give up on the ballot box altogether. Cynicism is cheap in politics, and Israelis complain about their politicians as passionately as they argue about hummus.

Yet they don't stay home.

Walk through Jerusalem or Tel Aviv on Election Day and the atmosphere feels strangely festive, almost electric. Cafes spill onto sidewalks. Families push strollers toward neighborhood polling stations. Volunteers in matching T-shirts wave party flags at major intersections, shouting slogans over honking horns while drivers lean out their windows to argue policy at red lights.

There is a reason for that intensity. In a small country where almost everyone knows someone serving in the military, where a single policy shift affects your taxes, your commute, and your family's safety within months, politics is never an abstract spectator sport. Nobody has the luxury of pretending it doesn't touch them.

When the curtain closes behind you in that elementary school classroom, the noise outside drops away. For ten quiet seconds, there are no pundits, no coalition negotiators, no party bosses. Just a fluorescent light humming overhead, a tray of white paper slips, and a country waiting to see which way the arithmetic tips next.

PR

Penelope Russell

An enthusiastic storyteller, Penelope Russell captures the human element behind every headline, giving voice to perspectives often overlooked by mainstream media.